There’s No Bonus Points for Style

I was in a meeting yesterday and realized partway through that the outcome was going my way. The decision was landing where I wanted it to land.

At the same time, I noticed several people in the room whose mental models I disagreed with. Their reasoning bothered me. Their framing was off. Part of me wanted to speak up and correct the record.

But I didn’t. Because I realized something. I didn’t need to.

You know why?

The outcome was already going my way. The only reason to say something would be to make sure my opinion was heard. To get my perspective on the record. To make sure everyone knew I had the right take.

But…who cares? I wasn’t winning any points for running up the score. There’s no bonus for winning by a wider margin.

This is harder than it sounds. When you disagree with someone’s reasoning, even if you agree with their conclusion, there’s this itch to correct them. To make sure the right logic is on the table. To not let a bad mental model go unchallenged. To make sure the right people get the right credit, and everyone knows why you want the decision to be the way it is.

But sometimes that’s just ego. You’re not improving the outcome. You’re just making sure everyone knows you were smart.

I think this is an underrated leadership skill: knowing when to shut up.

If the results are going your way, you don’t need to pile on. You don’t need to “well actually” your way to a bigger victory. You can just let it land. Save your capital for the fights that actually matter.

Not every meeting needs your opinion. Sometimes the best contribution is the one you don’t make.

Leave a comment